A Comparative study of Yashtimadhukadivarti & Diclofenac
Sodium Suppositories in the management of Parikartika
W.S.R to Fissure in ano
Research article
Anantkumar V Shekokar1*, Kanchan M Borkar2,
Mayur A Patil3, Vilasrao
Jagatap4
1*.
Reader & HOD 2. Lecturer, 3. P.G.
Scholar, S.V.N.H Ayurved College, Rahuri. Email-dranantkumarshekokar@gmail.com , Mobile: 09860376534
4.
Professor and HOD, S C M Aryangla Vaidyak
Mahavidyalaya,Satara.
Abstract:
Now a days many people are suffering from problem of Malavashtambha
(Constipation) and that is the main cause of Parikartikapresent
study is designed for evaluation of efficacy of Yashatimadhukadivarti
as a local application in comparison of Diclofenac Sodium
suppositories. The study is a
randomised, Single blind, Comparative
Study of 60 Patients of Fissure in ano. The patients were divided into two Groups i.e trial group consisting of 30 patients treated with yashatimadhukadivarti in the Morning after
defecation for 21 days while in control group 30 patients were treated with Diclofenac Sodium Suppositories in morning after defecationfor 21 days. The Observations are done and result
are obtained using t test.
Result
and conclusion: Majority of the cases show a complete healing of the ulcer or
fissure in ano within three weeks under the influence
of Yashtimadhukadi Varti
& this formulation is economical ,easy to apply
with no side effect.
Key words: Yashatimadhukadivarti,
Suppositories, Parikartika, Fissure in ano, Constipation, Toda, Burning sensation, Anal sphincter spasm.
Introduction:
In Ayurveda, Parikartika
is mentioned as a Vaman, Virechan and Basti vyapat. (1)
Parikartika
is defined as localized cutting pain within the region of guda
(2). Chakrapani mentioned synonyms of Parikatika as a Kshatgud
and Vikartika (3). According to modern science
fissure is defined as longitudinal ulcer in the lower anal canal.
Acharya Vagbhata also explained parikartika
in the Chapter of Atisar Grahni Dosha Nidan
. According to Vagbhata the patient suffering from Vatik
atisar has complaints of scanty motion and Hard stoo.while passing
through anal canal it tears the anal margin causing parikartika.
This disease also most commonly seen during pregnancy period
in the females. Kashyapa has stated 3
types of parikartika i.e. vataj
pittaj, & kaphaj & treatment accordingly in
pregnant lady (4). hetu of parikatika
are tikshna, lavan
yukta, ruksha aushadhi in patient suffering from Shram
, Mandagni & Mrudu koshtha (5).Acharya
Sushruta has
mentioned treatment of Parikartika
as Deepan.,Pachan,
Anuloman ,Sthanik
Snehan- Swedan
and Dusta Vranavat Chikitsa,Application
of Yasthimadukadi varti
having properties of vrana shodan & ropan which comes
under heading of dustha vrana
chikitsa.
Aims &
Objectives:
1.
To evaluate the efficacy Yashatimadhukadivarti
for local application.
2.
To compare the effect of Yashatimadhukadivarti & Diclofenac
Sodium Suppositories in the management of Parikatika w.s.r to fissure in ano.
3.
To derive a standard an easily
accessible and Cost effective treatment for fissure in ano.
Materials &
Methods:
Clinical
study
A) Study
design A randomized single bind comparative study in 60 patients.
B) Selection
of Patient Patient with Sign & Symptom of fissure.
Method:
Examination
i) History of
Patients
ii) Systemic examination
iii)
Local examination
a) Inspection
b) Palpation
c) Digital
rectal examination
iv)
Investigation: Routine blood
investigation e.g. CBC, BSL, BT, CT, Blood Urea, urine routine & microscopc examination, stool examination for Ova &
Cyst.
v)
Specific investigation like VDRL, Culture & Sensitivity of wound if
discharged presents & histopathological
examination when required.
Selection of the
patients:
Inclusion
criteria
1. Age
all age groups
2. Sex
both male & female
3. Acute
fissure (within 21 days)
4. Primary
fissure
Exclusion
criteria
1. Chronic
fissure with tag
2. Secondary
fissure
3. Internal
piles
4. Ext. Thrombosed piles
5. Rectal
polyp
6. Proctitis
7. CA of
Anus & Rectum
8. HIV
anal syndrome.
Total
number of the patients taken for the study was divided in two groups
·
Group
A
(Experimental Group): 30 patients were treated with yashatimadhukadivarti
10 gm.
·
Group
B
(Control Group): 30 patients were treated with Diclofenac
Sodium 100 mg Suppositories.
Drug study
Drug Material:
Yashatimadhukadivarti was prepared with Yashatimadhu kalka,
Krushna Tila
Kalka, Ghruta
and Madhu (6)
Yashatimadhukadivarti was prepared
at S.V.N.H.Ayurved College Rahuri,
in the Department of shalya tantra
& Diclofenac sodium suppositories were used
from college medical stores of Neon Pharma (Brand
name-Justtin) .
Route of
administration Anal Route
Dose
Yashtimadhukadi varti 10 gm & Diclofenac
Sodium Suppositories 100 mg once in a day
Time
morning after defecation
Duration of
treatment
- 21 days
Follow up
Every 5 days
Criteria
of Assessment:
Sr. No. |
Symptoms |
Absent |
Mild |
Moderate |
Severe |
Makedly Severe |
1 |
Gudashula |
0 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
2 |
Gudadadha |
0 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
3 |
GudaRaktasrava |
0 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
4 |
Kandu |
0 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
5 |
Gudasrava |
0 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
6 |
Malavashtmba |
0 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
7 |
Mutrasang |
0 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
8 |
Aruchi |
0 |
1 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
Result obtained from the study was
assessed in the terms of percentage of relief as follows:-
Incurable - Below
25%
Improved - 25% to 50%
Markedly improved - 51%
to 75 %
Cured
- More
than 75%
Observation
& Result
Table No 1:
Observation according to Nature of Diet
.Diet |
Group A |
Group B |
Veg |
6 (20%) |
5 (16.67%) |
Non- Veg |
24 (80%) |
25 (83.33%) |
Total |
30 (100%) |
30 (100%) |
Table No 2
Observation According to Kostha.
Kostha |
Group A |
Group B |
Krura |
19(63.33%) |
20 (66.67%) |
Madhyam |
11(36.67%) |
10 (33.33%) |
Mruda |
00 |
00 |
Table
No 3 Observation according to Sphincter Spasm
Spasm |
Group A |
Group B |
Present |
28 (93.33%) |
29 (96.67%) |
Absent |
02 (6.67%) |
1 (3.33%) |
Table
No 4 Statistical analysis for Improvement in Gudshula in two groups
Variable |
Mean
Difference |
S.E |
Applied test |
Calculated t
Value |
1 day |
1.43 |
0.21 |
Unpaired test |
6.97 |
6 day |
0.87 |
0.18 |
Unpaired test |
4.89 |
11 day |
0.83 |
0.17 |
Unpaired test |
4.84 |
16 day |
0.17 |
0.14 |
Unpaired test |
1.15 |
21 day |
0.03 |
0.07 |
Unpaired test |
0.46 |
The
table shows the statistical analysis for relief in gudshula
in two different group where the t value shows the
significant value at 1st day & there after till 11 day after 11
day of treatment both group shows equal results in gudshula.
It means that said formulation can be used to relieve gudshula.
Table No 5 Statistical
analysis for Improvement in Guddaha in two groups
Variable |
Mean
Difference |
S.E |
Applied test |
Calculated tValue |
1 day |
0.3 |
0.15 |
Unpaired test |
2.0 |
6 day |
0.43 |
0.15 |
Unpaired test |
2.85 |
11 day |
0.7 |
0.13 |
Unpaired test |
5.52 |
16 day |
0.73 |
0.14 |
Unpaired test |
5.27 |
21 day |
0.73 |
0.09 |
Unpaired test |
8.38 |
The
table shows the statistical analysis for relief in Guddaha
in two different group where the t value shows the
significant value at 1 day & there after till 21 day of treatment both group shows equal results
in Guddaha. It means that said formulation can
be used to relieve Guddaha.
Table No 6 Cardinal Symptoms Wise % of Relief at 21 Day
Symptoms |
Group A |
Group B |
Gudashula |
95.92 |
96.81 |
Gudadaha |
97.70 |
75.00 |
Gudasrava |
100 |
56.00 |
Malavashtmbha |
89.66 |
65.63 |
Kandu |
100 |
53.66 |
Mutrasang |
80.00 |
00 |
Aruchi |
100 |
18.18 |
Table No 7 Total
Effect of Therapy on 60 Patient of Parikartika
in Both Group.
Criteria |
Group A |
Group B |
Total |
||
Patients |
% |
Patients |
% |
% |
|
Cured |
30 |
100 |
11 |
36.66 |
68.33 |
Markedly improved |
0 |
0 |
19 |
63.33 |
31.66 |
Improved |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
Unchanged |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
0 |
Mode of Action:
Yashatimadhukadivarti
contain drugs which are having Vrana Shodhana & Ropana
Properties. These drugs posses Vata
Pitta, Shaman Properties. The disease is
aVata Pitta predominant
(7). Ghrita & madhu
in Combination possesses Vrana Shodhan & Ropana Properties &
they reduce Vata Pitta.
Therefore the action of the drug is enhanced by Ghrit.
It also reduces the Rukshata of Vayu
& Maintains the normal tone of muscles. According to morden
pharmacological action this combination has a potent Anti inflamataory
and steroidal activity.( 8 ) The relief of severe pain
within 24 hours is remarkable about this drug.
DISCUSSION &
CONCLUSION
Majority of the cases show a complete healing of the ulcer or
fissure within 3 weeks time under the influence of Yashtimadhukadi
varti & by the end of 4 weeks almost all the cases have a complete
healing while with Diclofenac sodium this period is
extended to 4 weeks in most of the cases.
The use of Yashtimadhukadi
varti has a definite advantage in the
treatment of fissure in ano in terms of relief of
cardinal symptoms, spasm & quick healing of the ulcer. Lastly the
experimental management was found to be very effective in this disease.
REFERENCES
1. Pt. kashinatha shastri charaksamhita, reprint 2001, Varanasi Chaukhambha
Bharati Academy, page no 1041.
2. Kaviraj Ambikadutta Shastri Susrut Samhita ,13 edition, reprint 2002, Varanasi, Chaukhambha
Sanskrit Sansthan. page No
151.
3. Dr. Anantkumar Shekokar & Dr. Kanchan Shekokar, Shalya part 2, second edition, Ahmednagar,
Shantanu Prakashan 2010,
page No 306.
4. Srisatyapala Bhisagacharya, Kashyapa Samhita, 1st edition, reprint 2009, Varanasi, Chaukhambha Sanskrit Sansthan page no 299.
5. Kaviraj Ambikadutta Shastri, Susrut Samhita, 13 edition,
reprint 2002, Varanasi, Chaukhambha Sanskrit Sansthan. page No 151.
6. Dr.Pashmina Joshi,TO study the effect of Yashtimadhukadi
yog in management of parikartika
W.S.R. to fissure in ano, 2004, I.P.G.T. & R.A., G.A.U.,Jamnagar.
7. Kaviraj Ambikadutta Shastri, Susrut Samhita, 13 edition,
reprint 2002, Varanasi, Chaukhambha Sanskrit Sansthan. page No 158.
8. Kirtikar and Basu ,2nd
edition , reprint 1997 ,international book distributor deharadun
(Uttaranchal ),vol.1st,p-728.
*****